Skip to main content
3 men climbing on ladder

Case Study: New York Scaffold Fall — Owner and General Contractor Liable Under Labor Law §240(1)

Illustrative composite — This case study combines facts from multiple real matters and anonymizes details. Individual outcomes depend on the specific facts, applicable state law, and procedural posture.

Case Study: New York Scaffold Fall — Owner and General Contractor Liable Under Labor Law §240(1)

The Situation

The client, a Korean-speaking carpenter employed by a subcontractor, was working on the renovation of a residential building in New York City. The project involved the building owner, a general contractor overseeing the work, and several subcontractors, including the client’s employer. Like many construction workers, the client did much of his work from a mobile scaffold platform that raised him well above floor level.

While the client was working on the platform, he fell about 12 feet to the ground. A guardrail section had been removed and was never replaced, and the scaffold’s wheels had not been locked. The fall left him with a fractured wrist and a shoulder injury that required surgery. For a carpenter who depends on his hands and arms, these were serious injuries that affected his ability to work and his family’s financial stability.

The triggering event came when the general contractor’s insurer responded to the claim. The insurer argued that the worker had been careless and that his own employer, not the owner, was responsible for what happened. Faced with this position, and with the added difficulty of handling the process in a second language, the client turned to Song Law Firm for help.

The Legal Issues

New York’s Labor Law §240(1), often called the “Scaffold Law,” gives special protection to workers exposed to elevation-related risks. It places responsibility for providing proper safety devices, such as scaffolds, guardrails and similar protection, on owners and contractors. That duty is non-delegable: an owner or general contractor generally cannot avoid it by pointing to a subcontractor. When the statute is violated and the violation is a proximate cause of the worker’s injury, liability is often described as absolute. In that situation, the worker’s own comparative negligence is not a defense.

The statute does have limits. Courts have recognized that if the owner and contractor provided adequate safety devices and the worker’s own conduct was the sole proximate cause of the accident, the statute does not impose liability. The key question in many scaffold cases is therefore whether proper protection was actually provided. A separate issue is how the claim fits with workers’ compensation. An injured worker’s own employer is generally shielded from a lawsuit by the workers’ compensation system. Any recovery from third parties, such as an owner or general contractor, may be subject to the compensation carrier’s lien.

  • N.Y. Labor Law §240(1): Requires owners and contractors to provide proper safety devices for elevation-related work, and imposes liability when a failure to do so causes injury.
  • Rocovich v. Consolidated Edison Co., 78 N.Y.2d 509 (1991): A leading Court of Appeals decision explaining that the statute aims to protect workers by placing ultimate responsibility for safety on owners and contractors, and that it applies to elevation-related hazards.
  • Blake v. Neighborhood Housing Services of N.Y. City, 1 N.Y.3d 280 (2003) (sole proximate cause): Clarifies that liability depends on a statutory violation that proximately causes the injury. A worker’s own conduct defeats the claim only when it is the sole proximate cause of the accident.
  • N.Y. Workers’ Compensation Law §29 (carrier lien): Addresses third-party actions by injured workers, including the workers’ compensation carrier’s lien on a recovery from a third party.

Song Law Firm’s Strategy

Identifying the right defendants. The insurer’s argument that the client’s employer was to blame was, in an important sense, beside the point. Song Law Firm explained to the client that his own employer is generally shielded by workers’ compensation, so a lawsuit against the employer was not the path forward. Instead, the firm brought the claim against the building owner and the general contractor as third parties. Under Labor Law §240(1), they carried the non-delegable duty to provide proper safety devices regardless of which company employed the client. Framing the case this way turned the insurer’s “blame the employer” position into an acknowledgment that the defendants could not shift their own statutory duty to someone else.

Pleading Labor Law §240(1) and confronting the carelessness argument. The firm pleaded Labor Law §240(1) directly. The client’s work on a raised mobile scaffold was a classic elevation-related risk. The firm emphasized that, under the statute, the worker’s comparative negligence is not a defense when the required protection was not provided. This answered the insurer’s claim that the worker had been careless. Even if the defendants could point to something the client might have done differently, that would not excuse a failure to supply a complete guardrail and a properly secured scaffold.

Building the evidence to defeat “sole proximate cause.” The defendants’ strongest remaining argument was that the client’s own actions were the sole proximate cause of his fall. Under Blake, that defense depends on adequate safety devices having been provided in the first place. Song Law Firm gathered photographs, the site safety log and co-worker statements. Together, this evidence showed that no adequate guardrail was in place and that the wheels were not locked. Because the safety devices themselves were deficient, the accident could not be blamed solely on the worker. This record set up a motion for partial summary judgment on liability, which can narrow a case to the question of damages.

Coordinating the compensation lien. Because the client had received workers’ compensation benefits, the carrier held a lien on any third-party recovery under Workers’ Compensation Law §29. The firm coordinated with the carrier throughout the case. The goal was for any settlement to account for the lien properly and for the client to keep as much of the recovery as possible.

Outcome and Takeaways

The court granted partial summary judgment on liability under Labor Law §240(1) against both the building owner and the general contractor. With liability established, the case resolved in a confidential settlement, and the workers’ compensation lien was negotiated down as part of the resolution.

For construction workers in New York, and for New Jersey residents who work on New York job sites, a few practical lessons stand out:

  • Look beyond your employer. Workers’ compensation generally bars suits against your own employer, but owners and general contractors may be responsible as third parties.
  • Your own mistakes may not end your claim. In a Scaffold Law case, comparative negligence is not a defense when proper safety devices were not provided.
  • Preserve evidence early. Photographs, safety logs and co-worker accounts can be decisive, especially against a “sole proximate cause” argument.
  • Do not overlook the lien. A workers’ compensation lien can significantly affect what you actually receive, so it should be addressed as part of any resolution.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


Contact Us

Song Law Firm, LLC
Phone: 201.461.0031
Email: mail@songlawfirm.com
Website: songlawfirm.com
Office: Parker Plaza, 400 Kelby Street, Suite 1900, Fort Lee, NJ 07024
Hours: Monday–Friday 09:00–18:00 ET

This material is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes depend on the applicable state law and the specific facts of each case; please consult a licensed attorney. Attorney Advertising — NJ Rules of Professional Conduct 7.1. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Scroll to Top