Skip to main content
a couple of men standing on top of a roof

Case Study: 1099 Installer Misclassified — NJ ABC Test Establishes Employee Status and Unpaid Overtime

Illustrative composite — This case study combines facts from multiple real matters and anonymizes details. Individual outcomes depend on the specific facts, applicable state law, and procedural posture.

Case Study: 1099 Installer Misclassified — NJ ABC Test Establishes Employee Status and Unpaid Overtime

The Situation

The client was an appliance and HVAC installation technician in New Jersey. For several years, one installation company paid him on a 1099 basis, treating him as an independent contractor rather than an employee. On paper, the arrangement suggested he was running his own business. In practice, his working life looked very different.

The client regularly worked 50-60 hours a week on schedules the company set. He wore the company’s uniform, drove routes the company assigned, and worked only for that company. Despite these long weeks, he was never paid overtime. No taxes or other payroll amounts were withheld from his pay, and he received none of the protections that usually come with employment. Like many workers in his position, he accepted the 1099 label because that was how the company described the relationship from the start.

The situation came to a head when the client was injured on the job. When he turned to the company for help, it told him he was “not an employee” and that he had no coverage. Suddenly the label that had seemed like a mere paperwork detail threatened to leave him without medical support or wage replacement while he recovered. At that point, he sought help from Song Law Firm.

The Legal Issues

The central question was whether the client was truly an independent contractor or an employee who had been misclassified. In New Jersey, the answer does not depend on what the company calls the worker or which tax form it issues. Instead, New Jersey applies the “ABC test.” Under this test, a worker who performs services for pay is presumed to be an employee. The company can overcome that presumption only by proving all three prongs: (A) the worker is free from the company’s control or direction over the performance of the work; (B) the work is either outside the usual course of the company’s business or performed outside all of its places of business; and (C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business. If the company fails to prove even one prong, the worker is treated as an employee.

The Supreme Court of New Jersey has confirmed that this ABC test governs whether a worker is an employee for purposes of New Jersey’s wage laws. Once employee status is established, the protections of the New Jersey Wage and Hour Law apply, including the right to overtime pay. New Jersey’s 2019 wage theft amendments strengthened those protections, including by making liquidated damages available and extending the look-back period for wage claims to six years. Separately, the client’s injury raised the question of workers’ compensation coverage, which in New Jersey generally depends on the worker’s status as an employee rather than the label the company chose.

  • N.J.S.A. 43:21-19(i)(6)(A)-(C) (ABC test) — Sets out the three-prong ABC test. A worker is presumed to be an employee unless the company proves all three prongs.
  • Hargrove v. Sleepy’s, LLC, 220 N.J. 289 (2015) — The Supreme Court of New Jersey held that the ABC test is the standard for deciding employee status in New Jersey wage claims, which places the burden on the company rather than the worker.
  • N.J.S.A. 34:11-56a et seq. (NJ Wage and Hour Law) — New Jersey’s core wage statute, which provides minimum wage and overtime protections for employees and allows employees to recover unpaid wages.

Song Law Firm’s Strategy

Song Law Firm began by framing the case around New Jersey’s ABC test rather than around the company’s paperwork. Because the law presumes employee status and places the burden on the company to prove every prong, this approach shifted the focus to what the company would have to show, not what the client would have to disprove. The team gathered evidence of the company’s control over the client’s work, including the schedules it set, the uniform it required, and the routes it assigned. While control (prong A) was clearly a weak point for the company, the firm chose to build its strongest arguments where the company’s position was most vulnerable.

That meant concentrating on prongs B and C. Installation of appliances and HVAC systems was the company’s core business, so the client’s work fell squarely within its usual course of business, and prong B failed. The client also had no independent business of his own: he had no separate customer base, did not market his services to others, and worked only for this one company. Without an independently established trade, prong C failed as well. Because the company needed to prove all three prongs, showing that even one failed was enough to establish employee status. Demonstrating that two prongs failed made the company’s position far harder to defend.

With employee status firmly supported, the firm turned to damages. Employers who misclassify workers often keep poor time records, so Song Law Firm reconstructed the client’s hours from the company’s own dispatch records, GPS logs and text messages. These sources showed when jobs were assigned, when the client was on the road, and how long his workdays actually ran. Using this reconstruction, the team calculated the unpaid overtime owed under the NJ Wage and Hour Law. The firm then asserted liquidated damages and invoked the longer six-year look-back period available after New Jersey’s 2019 wage theft amendments, which allowed the claim to reach further back across the client’s years with the company. At the same time, the firm raised the workers’ compensation coverage issue directly, making clear that the company’s “not an employee” position could not stand and that the client’s injury had to be addressed through the proper channel.

Outcome and Takeaways

Faced with the ABC test analysis, the documented record of the client’s hours, and the exposure created by liquidated damages and the extended look-back period, the company conceded that the client was an employee. In a confidential settlement, it paid back overtime plus liquidated damages and attorney’s fees. The client’s on-the-job injury was routed to workers’ compensation, so he could pursue the benefits that the company had initially claimed he did not have.

For workers in New Jersey or New York who are paid on a 1099 basis but whose work looks like a regular job, this case offers several practical lessons:

  • The label is not the final word. In New Jersey, a 1099 form does not decide whether you are an employee. The ABC test does, and it starts from a presumption of employment.
  • Keep your own records. Schedules, dispatch messages, texts, mileage and GPS data can help prove the hours you actually worked, even if the company kept no time records.
  • Look at the company’s core business. If your work is the very service the company sells, and you have no independent business of your own, the company may have difficulty proving you are a contractor.
  • Do not assume an injury leaves you without coverage. If you were misclassified, you may still be entitled to workers’ compensation as an employee, and timing can matter for both wage and injury claims.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


Contact Us

Song Law Firm, LLC
Phone: 201.461.0031
Email: mail@songlawfirm.com
Website: songlawfirm.com
Office: Parker Plaza, 400 Kelby Street, Suite 1900, Fort Lee, NJ 07024
Hours: Monday–Friday 09:00–18:00 ET

This material is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes depend on the applicable state law and the specific facts of each case; please consult a licensed attorney. Attorney Advertising — NJ Rules of Professional Conduct 7.1. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Scroll to Top