Skip to main content
United States map

Multi-State Nexus Defense Success — Reducing Retroactive Sales Tax for Remote Sellers Post-Wayfair

Illustrative composite — This case study combines facts from multiple real matters and anonymizes details. Individual outcomes depend on the specific facts, applicable state law, and procedural posture.

Multi-State Nexus Defense Success — Reducing Retroactive Sales Tax for Remote Sellers Post-Wayfair

The Situation

The client was a New Jersey-based online wholesale seller that shipped products to customers in several states. Like many growing e-commerce businesses, it made part of its sales directly through its own channels and another portion through a large online marketplace. The client’s operations, inventory, and day-to-day business activities were in New Jersey. For years, the client had focused on fulfilling orders and serving customers, without a clear picture of how its out-of-state sales might create tax obligations in other jurisdictions.

That changed when nexus questionnaires and assessment notices arrived from more than one state at the same time. Several states had sent sales-tax inquiries and proposed assessments that reached back years. Each one cited “economic nexus” as the basis for the tax and added penalties and interest on top of the claimed tax. Because the notices came from different taxing authorities, each with its own forms, deadlines, and procedures, the client faced the prospect of fighting on several fronts at once.

The client’s main concern was understandable. Sales tax is normally collected from customers at the time of sale. Here, the states were demanding tax on transactions that had closed long ago, and the client could not go back and collect it from wholesale buyers. Left unaddressed, the combined exposure across multiple states, plus penalties and interest, threatened the business’s financial stability. The client turned to Song Law Firm for help building an organized, state-by-state response.

The Legal Issues

For decades, a state generally could not require an out-of-state seller to collect its sales tax unless the seller had a physical presence in that state, such as an office, employees, or inventory. In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court changed that framework. It held that a state may require remote sellers to collect and remit sales tax based on their economic activity in the state, even without a physical presence. After that decision, many states adopted “economic nexus” laws. These laws set sales-volume or transaction thresholds that, once met, trigger a duty to register, collect, and remit tax. The thresholds, effective dates, and measurement periods vary from state to state. So whether a particular seller owed tax in a particular state, and starting when, depends on the facts and on that state’s specific rules.

A second development was equally important for sellers using online marketplaces. Many states have adopted “marketplace facilitator” laws. Under these laws, a large online marketplace that facilitates sales by third-party sellers is responsible for collecting and remitting sales tax on those sales. When those rules apply, the underlying seller may not be the party responsible for the tax on marketplace transactions. Many states also offer voluntary disclosure programs. These programs generally allow a business that comes forward to resolve past liabilities on more favorable terms, which often include a limited look-back period and relief from penalties. Eligibility usually depends on the taxpayer’s circumstances and the stage of the state’s inquiry.

  • South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc. (U.S. Supreme Court, 2018) — The Supreme Court allowed states to require remote sellers to collect sales tax based on economic activity rather than physical presence. This opened the door to the economic-nexus laws the states relied on in their assessments. It also gave each state’s effective date a central role in determining which periods could properly be taxed.

Song Law Firm’s Strategy

The first step was to replace broad, years-long assessments with a precise, data-driven picture. Song Law Firm mapped each state’s economic-nexus effective date and threshold against the client’s actual sales by period. This mattered because a state’s economic-nexus law cannot reach back further than its own effective date. A seller also does not have a collection obligation in a given period unless its sales actually meet that state’s threshold under that state’s measurement rules. By working through the client’s sales history period by period and state by state, the firm could identify the periods in which the client had not crossed the threshold or in which the state’s law was not yet in effect. Those periods could then be challenged and removed from the assessments.

Next, the firm separated marketplace sales on which the marketplace facilitator was responsible for collecting and remitting tax. Because a portion of the client’s revenue came through a large online marketplace, the proposed assessments risked counting sales on which tax had already been, or should have been, handled by the marketplace. Isolating those transactions served two purposes. It prevented the client from being charged on sales for which it was not the responsible party, and it gave the states a clear, documented basis for reducing the amounts claimed. Depending on each state’s rules, it could also affect how the client’s remaining direct sales were analyzed for nexus purposes.

The firm then used voluntary disclosure agreements where available to limit the look-back period and seek penalty waivers. For states where the client had real exposure for some periods, voluntary disclosure offered a structured way to resolve the past while controlling how far back the liability reached. Penalty relief was a key goal, because penalties can add significantly to an assessment that is already hard to absorb. Finally, the firm registered the client in New Jersey and brought its New Jersey filings current. The client had a physical presence there, so its obligations were clear. Putting home-state compliance in order removed a potential vulnerability and showed good faith. It also gave the client a stable foundation for its multi-state compliance going forward.

Outcome and Takeaways

Through this coordinated approach, the client’s assessments were substantially reduced. Penalties were waived under voluntary disclosure, and the client avoided the open-ended, years-long exposure the initial notices had suggested. Just as important, Song Law Firm helped the client set up a compliant collection process going forward, so that its tax obligations in each relevant state are addressed as sales occur rather than years later. The client came out of the process with its past liabilities resolved and a clearer, more predictable path for growth.

For online and remote sellers based in New Jersey, New York, or elsewhere who receive similar notices, a few practical lessons stand out:

  • Do not accept a multi-year assessment at face value. Each state’s economic-nexus effective date and threshold should be compared against your actual sales, period by period.
  • Separate your marketplace sales. Where a marketplace facilitator was responsible for collecting and remitting tax, those sales may not belong in an assessment against you.
  • Explore voluntary disclosure early. Where it is available, it may limit the look-back period and provide penalty relief, but eligibility can depend on timing and the state’s prior contact with you.
  • Get your home state in order. Becoming current where you have a physical presence builds credibility and a foundation for ongoing compliance.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


Contact Us

Song Law Firm, LLC
Phone: 201.461.0031
Email: mail@songlawfirm.com
Website: songlawfirm.com
Office: Parker Plaza, 400 Kelby Street, Suite 1900, Fort Lee, NJ 07024
Hours: Monday–Friday 09:00–18:00 ET

This material is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice on any specific matter. Outcomes depend on the applicable state law and the specific facts of each case; please consult a licensed attorney. Attorney Advertising — NJ Rules of Professional Conduct 7.1. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Scroll to Top